Marker text
“I was there in the glory days of The Catskills and the audiences were tough and demanding. They really sharpened your act. It was do or die. No Borscht Belt, no Mel Brooks.”
— Mel Brooks
During Sullivan County’s Silver Age (1890-1915), Hurleyville was home to nine farmhouses that welcomed summer boarders. In the time of Sullivan County’s Golden Age (1940-1965), also known as the Borscht Belt era, Hurleyville had about 32 hotels and 20 bungalow colonies.
The Columbia Hotel, built in 1891, was the largest hotel in Hurleyville, located on a hillside overlooking the town. The Columbia was the oldest continually operating hotel in the county when it closed in 1969.
Other hotels were the Butler Lodge, Grand View, Majestic, Kramers, and The Morningside. American comedian, director and producer Mel Brooks began his career at Butler Lodge as a teenager in the summer of 1941.
Hurleyville, NY Historic Marker Dedication Ceremony, July 21, 2024
Speakers:
Christina Antizzo, HPAC Chief Executive Officer
Marisa Scheinfeld, Marker Project
Louis Inghilterra, Marker Project
John Conway, Sullivan County Historian
Gary Dan, Morningside Hotel
Mark Kramer, Kramer's Hotel
Jacob Billig, Martin Billig and Robin Baer, Butler Lodge
Sam Sadigursky is a member of the Philip Glass Ensemble, has released 11 albums and tours with musicians such as David Byrne, Bruce Hornsby and Tom Jones. Sadigursky has performed at the Kennedy Center, Carnegie Hall, Brooklyn Academy of Music, Metropolitan Museum of Art, Newport Jazz Festival, among others.
The immersive SOLOMON DIARIES is a series of 3-albums written by Sadigursky inspired by the Borscht Belt. The music blends klezmer, jazz, American folk, and Middle Eastern rhythms in a “compelling musical remembrance of a bygone era.”
At HPAC the albums will be played as an intimate duo between Sadigursky on clarinet and Nathan Koci on accordion juxtaposed with images from The Borscht Belt. Koci, an accordionist and multi-instrumentalist, has played with the LA Opera, SF Opera, and was musical director of the acclaimed Broadway productions of Hadestown and Oklahoma!
PURCHASE TICKETS HERE:
Our Happening in Hurleyville will feature special slideshow premiering on Sunday, July 21 entitled CATSKILLAND: BILLBOARDS OF THE BORSCHT BELT during our HAPPENING IN HURLEYVILLE!
Set to a musical backdrop curated by Havurah Arts, this fascinating slideshow will transport you on a literal road trip through the mountains! Grab a seat and enjoy the ride as you pass by iconic Sullivan and Ulster County billboards and landscapes from the 1940s through the early 2000s. Documented for over 60 years by Keller Signs and now part of the collection of the Sullivan County Historical Society & Museum, we’re thrilled to partner with the SCHS and unearth these delightful images.
On view: July 21 from 12:30 - 4:00 pm at the Collaborative College High School, 202 Main St, Hurleyville, NY 12747
Butler Lodge Multiview, 1940s. Courtesy of Digital Commonwealth of Massachusetts
Born Melvin Kaminsky on June 28, 1926 in Williamsburg, Mel Brooks is an icon of comedy who began his career in the Borscht Belt in the 1940’s.
The Emmy, Grammy, Tony, and Oscar winner is the youngest of four children. A trip to see a Broadway show with his uncle at age 9 opened Brooks up to the world of entertainment and the arts. He’d soon discover his first love - the drums - and meet an early mentor, an actor named Don Appell, who helped him land a job one summer at the Butler Lodge in Hurleyville!
In the summer of 1941, at age 14, Brooks trekked to the Catskills to bus tables during the day and drum by night at the Butler Lodge. At the hotel, he ventured into stand-up comedy for the first time. One fateful night he stepped in for an actor, ended up ad-libbing, and received a room full of laughs.
Later in the Catskills, Brooks worked as a tummler (emcee), stand-up comic, social director and befriended budding comedian Sid Caesar. In Slide 2, Brooks recalls Don Appel, his early days at the Butler, Sid Caesar, and jam sessions in Liberty running jokes.
Brooks’ career skyrocketed in 1950 when he became a writer on Caesar’s “Your Show of Shows.” The popular variety series translated vaudevillian comedy for the small screen and featured satirical sketches with talent such as Neil Simon, Carl Reiner, Brooks and later, Woody Allen. The series changed the nature of TV humor, setting a standard for shows such as Saturday Night Live, Mad TV, The Carol Burnett Show and The Muppet Show.
Brooks went on to have an illustrious career as a film director, screenwriter, composer, lyricist, comedian, actor, and producer. Some of his iconic films include The Producers, Blazing Saddles, Young Frankenstein, The Naked Gun, Spaceballs, and Robin Hood: Men in Tights. He is currently filming Spaceballs 2.
1920s Brochure cover for the Morningside. Courtesy of the Catskills Institute
In June of 1963, Jim Henson (Yes, Jim Henson of the Muppets) ventured to the hamlet of Hurleyville for the Puppeteers of America. The annual festival, held at the New Morningside Hotel. The festival included five days of meetings, workshops, screenings, and performances gathering puppeteers from around the country. The event was a veritable “who’s who” of puppeteers and featured works by an eclectic array of performers and technicians, including Jim and his wife Jane.
Co-organized by Henson, the association’s president, along with local puppeteer Earl “Bud’ Wertheim, it’s never been exactly clear how or why Henson chose the New Morningside, but is speculated that Wertheim, a long-time resident of Sullivan County, played a role.
The New Morningside Hotel had grown out of an early 20th century Jewish boarding house—and was one of the first in the area. The hotel advertised the 1963 Puppeteer Festival to the public, with a display ad in the Liberty Register’s June 20th edition announcing afternoon and evening performances. Admission was 50 cents for children and $1 for adults in the afternoon and 75 cents for children and $1.25 for adults in the evening.
Following the New Morningside, Henson began work on a series of experimental films, numerous variety shows, and “Sesame Street,” developing new characters and honing his existing Muppets. The introduction of The Muppet Show in 1976 was a phenomenal success, reaching 235 million viewers in more than 100 countries and winning three Emmys in its five-year run. A series of Muppet movies followed starting with The Muppet Movie in 1979 whose iconic song, Rainbow Connection, sung by Henson as Kermit, was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Original Song the following year. Throughout the 1980’s, Jim explored new directions in television and film, developing the series Fraggle Rock, along with new characters and technologies for the award-winning The Storyteller, The Jim Henson Hour, Dinosaurs and for his groundbreaking fantasy films, The Dark Crystal and Labyrinth.
Henson's untimely passing in May 1990 was met with a worldwide outpouring of love and renewed appreciation of his imagination and artistry. He endures as much of an American icon as his creations. We are so excited to honor the Morningside and Hurleyville’s extraordinary history on July 21. We hope you’ll join us!
-- Excerpts from the May 17, 2019 RETROSPECT by John Conway and The Jim Henson Archive. Images courtesy of The Jim Henson Company
The Columbia Hotel, 1900s. Courtesy of Marisa Scheinfeld.
Summers in NYC have always been hot and humid, so if one can afford to get out of town for a week or the whole summer, one goes. If you were a recent Jewish immigrant, you likely headed to the Catskill Mountains, as did my grandparents. At first they’d rent a bungalow for 4 months of the summer, (my mother remembered she never spent a summer in NYC as sne was growing up). Then in 1938 they purchased one acre of forested land in Hurleyville, a hamlet in the town of Fallsburg in Sullivan County, NY. (Monticello, Woodstock & Bethel are in the same county.
Abe and Anna cleared an area and built one cottage on it that first year and two more the following two years. They also paved driveways leading to each cottage and dug a 3,000 foot well (the depth is according to Anna). Then in 1943 they purchased another acre, this time from the Mitteers, who had a dairy farm adjacent to the Pearl’s property. They built 4 more cottages (one a year), including a duplex. As I recall, the ground sloped gently upwards from the main road and just behind the cottages was a substantial rocky hill, I’d guess to be 20 feet high. Several apple trees grew alongside the main cottage where they lived. On the other end of the property, behind the last cottages, grew blueberry bushes. A long stone wall marked the boundary between their and the Mitteer’s property.
[‘Early Jan. 2022 I spoke with a Sullivan Co. Records Clerk, Chris Knapp (his family has lived in Hurleyville for the past 200 years). Based on the fact that I knew my grandmother’s property was next to the Mitteer Farm (now defunct for many years) and a letter my grandmother kept from a Sullivan Co. lawyer referring to “a deed from Fred W. Mitteer and Alice Mitteer to Anna Pearl, dated Sept. 1, 1943 and recorded Sept. 3, 1943 in Book 362 of Deeds at Page 269” , Chris was able to search the microfiche re. this transfer of property. (Btw, Anna had handwritten on the letter that they paid $200 for that parcel).
A couple of the original bungalows might still be standing, the addresses for them are 63 and 67 Mitteer Rd. Chris said this deed refers to an additional parcel that gave them a total of 2 ½ acres, which likely included the current addresses of 61 and 57 Mitteer Rd. . And which corroborates Anna’s memoir. Anna sold the entire property in 1964 to Irving Warsh, who later sold it to 6 individuals, who then split it up. The tax lot #’s are: Fallsburg section 32.-1-11.1 and 32.1-11.2
The Mitteer Farm went defunct, maybe in the late 1960’s and they sold their property to developers. There aren’t any Mitteers still livin
Anna & Micki would spend every summer at the Catskill property. Abe would only go up on weekends, when he’d drive families to the nearby hotels. He continued to work nights driving fares around NYC during the week. Every Fall they’d make any necessary repairs, check & repair the roofs, paint and secure all the window shutters, and in the Spring get the cottages opened and aired out for the new season. Anna continued to maintain the property until she was 65, about 14 years after Abe died of a heart attack at the age of 57 in 1948.
Applebee Inn (later Fairlawn Farm/Fairlawn Acres)
Arcadia Lake
Astor Hotel
Brookhaven (previously Schindler's Prairie House, then Berger's Mansion,then LaSalle Hotel)
Butler Lodge
Columbia Farms Hotel
Columbia Star House
Echo Hill House
Forest Inn
Garden House
Golden Hotel
Grand View Hotel
Kaufman's
King David Hotel(formerly Wellworth)
Kramer's on Luzon Lake
Hotel La Salle
Lake Shore House
Luzon Lodge
Majestic (later Dunwoodie)
Midwood Hotel
Morningside Hotel
Orlowsky's
Peneroyal Hill Farm House
Pollack's Grand View
Purul's House
Purvis House
Richmond Hotel
Rosenthal Mountain House
Salon's Lodge
Schacter's Pearl House
Sunset Hotel
Wayside Inn
Andresky's Bungalows
Arcadia Lake
Chenkin's Farm
Clinton House
Columbia Hill
Deutsch
Fairlawn Farms
Fleisher's
Fried Bungalows
L&L
Louis Schatz
Lubin's Linda House
Melchick's
Nickolas Nysky
Osdoby's
Replansky's Bungalows
Philip Salov
Pine Knoll Cottages
Sixcess Bungalows
Shat'z Cozy Cottages
Copyright © 2024 Borscht Belt Historical Marker Project - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by GoDaddy
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.